Why Some Vets Advise Against Owning a German Shepherd: Exploring the Controversy

German Shepherds are among the most admired and beloved dog breeds worldwide. Renowned for their intelligence, loyalty, and versatility, these canines have long been revered for their exceptional service as working and family dogs. However, a controversial debate has emerged among veterinarians and dog experts regarding the ownership of German Shepherds. Some within the veterinary community have raised concerns about the breed’s potential health issues, temperament challenges, and specialized needs. This has prompted a considerable amount of discussion and deliberation among current and prospective dog owners, considering the merits and drawbacks of bringing a German Shepherd into their homes. Exploring both sides of this contentious discourse offers valuable insights for anyone considering welcoming a German Shepherd into their life.

Quick Summary
Some vets may say they wouldn’t own a German Shepherd due to their potential for aggressive behavior if not properly trained and socialized. German Shepherds are powerful and active dogs that require regular exercise and mental stimulation, and they can become destructive if not provided with an outlet for their energy. Additionally, the breed is prone to certain health issues such as hip dysplasia and degenerative myelopathy, which may make some vets hesitant to recommend them as pets.

Historical Background Of German Shepherds

The German Shepherd breed has a rich historical background that dates back to the late 19th century. Originally developed in Germany, these dogs were initially bred for herding sheep. Their exceptional intelligence, strength, and agility made them ideal for this task, and they quickly gained popularity as a working dog breed.

However, their role expanded during World War I when they were used as military and police dogs due to their loyalty, bravery, and keen sense of smell. This period marked the breed’s transition from herding to serving in various official capacities, which solidified their reputation as versatile and dependable dogs.

Today, German Shepherds are widely recognized for their use in police and military work, search and rescue operations, and as guide dogs for individuals with disabilities. Their unwavering loyalty, intelligence, and protective nature have made them a popular choice for families and individuals seeking a devoted and versatile companion. Understanding the breed’s historical background provides insight into their capabilities and characteristics, shedding light on why they may not be suitable for everyone.

Health Concerns And Genetic Predispositions

German Shepherds are known to be prone to several health concerns and genetic predispositions, which have led some veterinary professionals to advise against owning this breed. One of the primary health issues that affect German Shepherds is hip dysplasia, a genetic condition that causes malformation of the hip joint, leading to crippling arthritis. Additionally, they are also susceptible to elbow dysplasia, a similar condition affecting the elbow joints.

Furthermore, German Shepherds are prone to degenerative myelopathy, a progressive neurological disease that can lead to paralysis. This breed is also genetically predisposed to certain types of cancers, including hemangiosarcoma and osteosarcoma. These potential health concerns can result in significant emotional and financial burden for pet owners. It is important for prospective German Shepherd owners to be aware of these health issues and work closely with a veterinarian to monitor and manage their pet’s health proactively.

Behavioral Challenges And Training Needs

German Shepherds are known for their intelligence and loyalty, but they also come with behavioral challenges and training needs that make them a handful for some owners. These dogs are highly active and require significant exercise and mental stimulation to prevent boredom and destructive behavior. Without proper training and socialization, they can exhibit territorial and protective behaviors that may be challenging to manage.

Additionally, German Shepherds are known for their strong prey drive and can be prone to chasing or nipping at moving objects, including children or other pets. This can be alarming for some owners, especially those with families or other animals in the household. Furthermore, their high energy levels and tendency to become overexcited can lead to excessive barking, jumping, or even aggression if not properly addressed through consistent training and positive reinforcement techniques.

In conclusion, while German Shepherds can make wonderful companions, their behavioral challenges and training needs should not be underestimated. Prospective owners must be prepared to invest time and effort in training, socialization, and providing the physical and mental enrichment these dogs require to thrive in a domestic setting.

Legal And Liability Issues

Legal and liability issues surrounding German Shepherds can be a significant concern for owners and potential adopters. While these dogs are known for their loyalty and protective nature, their reputation as guard dogs has led to increased scrutiny in legal and insurance realms. In some jurisdictions, German Shepherds may be classified as “dangerous dogs,” which can come with strict regulations, such as mandatory muzzling in public or special containment requirements.

Additionally, owners of German Shepherds may face challenges with homeowner’s insurance as these dogs are often considered high-risk breeds. Some insurance companies may refuse coverage or charge higher premiums for homes with German Shepherds, citing their potential for causing injuries or property damage. In the unfortunate event of a dog-related incident, owners of German Shepherds may also be at risk of legal action and liability claims, especially if their dog is involved in an altercation or bites someone. It’s vital for potential owners to be aware of these legal and liability considerations and to take proactive steps to mitigate risks and ensure the safety of their dog and others.

Exercise And Activity Requirements

German Shepherds are a high-energy breed that require ample exercise and activity to maintain their physical and mental well-being. Due to their working heritage as herding and protection dogs, they thrive in environments where they can be physically and mentally stimulated. A lack of proper exercise can lead to boredom, frustration, and potentially destructive behaviors such as excessive barking, digging, or chewing.

Owners considering a German Shepherd should be prepared to commit to daily exercise routines that include activities such as walking, running, hiking, agility training, and interactive play. Engaging in these physical activities not only helps the dog release pent-up energy but also strengthens the bond between the owner and the pet. Without adequate exercise, German Shepherds may become restless and develop behavioral issues, making them unsuitable for individuals who cannot dedicate the time and effort required to meet their exercise needs.

It is important for potential German Shepherd owners to understand the breed’s exercise requirements and to consider their own lifestyle and commitment to providing the necessary physical and mental stimulation before bringing one into their home. Regular exercise and activity are crucial for the overall well-being and happiness of a German Shepherd and should be a top priority for anyone considering this breed.

Financial Considerations Of Owning A German Shepherd

Owning a German Shepherd comes with significant financial considerations. From initial purchase or adoption costs to routine veterinary care, grooming, supplies, training, and potential medical expenses, the total cost of ownership can be substantial. German Shepherds are a large and active breed, which means they require more food and potential healthcare expenses compared to smaller breeds. Their size also means they may require larger crates, beds, and accessories, all of which add to the initial and ongoing costs of ownership.

In addition to routine expenses, potential emergency medical care needs to be factored in. German Shepherds are predisposed to certain health issues, such as hip dysplasia, which can be expensive to treat. Consulting with a veterinarian to understand potential healthcare costs specific to the breed is crucial to making an informed decision about ownership. Furthermore, adequate pet insurance or a dedicated emergency fund should be considered to prepare for unexpected expenses. Understanding and planning for the financial commitment required to care for a German Shepherd is essential for prospective owners to provide the best quality of life for their pet.

Alternative Perspectives And Success Stories

In the realm of alternative perspectives and success stories, it’s crucial to highlight that while some vets caution against owning German Shepherds due to potential behavior and health issues, many owners have found great success and fulfillment with the breed. These success stories often emphasize the importance of proper socialization, training, and regular exercise for the well-being of German Shepherds. By providing a loving and structured environment, owners have reported experiencing unwavering loyalty, intelligence, and admirable protective instincts in their German Shepherds.

Additionally, alternative perspectives from experienced dog trainers and behaviorists shed light on the potential for German Shepherds to thrive in the right circumstances. Through dedicated training and understanding of the breed’s specific needs, some owners have been able to cultivate strong bonds and highly disciplined companions. These alternative perspectives and success stories serve as a reminder that with the right care and commitment, German Shepherds can be incredible additions to the right households, showcasing their remarkable abilities as loyal and devoted family members.

Responsible Ownership And Education

Responsible ownership and education are crucial components for successfully owning a German Shepherd. Prospective owners must understand the breed’s needs and characteristics, as well as commit to providing adequate physical and mental stimulation. This includes regular exercise, training, and socialization to prevent behavioral issues and ensure a well-adjusted dog. Furthermore, education about the breed’s potential health issues, such as hip dysplasia and degenerative myelopathy, is essential for proactive care and early intervention.

Additionally, responsible ownership involves providing a safe and stimulating environment for the dog, which includes secure fencing, proper housing, and access to veterinary care. Understanding the breed’s protective nature and actively managing it through training and positive socialization experiences are also central to responsible ownership. Lastly, education about the importance of breed-specific legislation, responsible breeding practices, and ethical considerations when acquiring a German Shepherd is pivotal for promoting the welfare of the breed as a whole. Through responsible ownership and ongoing education, owners can foster a positive and fulfilling relationship with their German Shepherds while also promoting the well-being of the breed.


In light of the controversies surrounding German Shepherds and the varied perspectives within the veterinary community, it is evident that responsible ownership, proper training, and early socialization are crucial factors in shaping the behavior of these magnificent animals. While some vets may advise against owning a German Shepherd due to their potential for aggression, it is essential to recognize that individual temperament, upbringing, and environment play significant roles in the development of any dog. Rather than categorically dissuading individuals from considering a German Shepherd as a pet, a nuanced approach that emphasizes informed decision-making, thorough research, and proactive measures to ensure the well-being of both the dog and its surrounding community is imperative. Education and open dialogue within the veterinary profession will continue to play a pivotal role in navigating the complexities and dispelling misconceptions surrounding German Shepherds, ultimately enabling responsible individuals to experience the love and companionship that this breed can bring.

Leave a Comment